317-590-6729 tonya@hometoindy.com

Your Story, Our Mission

Hi, I’m Tonya McCarthy with NextHome Connection in Avon, Indiana. I can offer a wealth of knowledge and services to assist in all your real estate needs. My website has all the same features as the large national websites, but still keeps my local, friendly, customer-oriented approach. Feel free to view as many homes as you like, save the ones that appeal to you, ask as many questions as you need. I will be happy to work with you on finding and purchasing the perfect home. Be sure to sign up for daily alerts of homes for sale so you know the instant your dream house hits the market.

Please keep in mind that buying your new home may depend on selling your current home. I will be happy to evaluate and market your home for you. If you live outside my area, I can refer you to one of our many associates around the country. If you need anything at all, please contact me directly.

What are others saying?

Looking for more testimonials, reviews and ratings about our customer service? Click here to see more.

Tonya is a beautiful, caring lady. She will work hard to help you. I highly recommend her to everyone. I am a disabled veteran and will definitely recommend her to others. I guarantee you won’t find a person in her field that is on your side and will go all out to help you like she does. Thanks so much, Tonya McCarthy, for the hard work you’ve done to help me with my dream home.
Indianapolis, IN Homeowner

Tonya did a great job finding us our perfect home! She was very willing to look in new areas and direct us to the right house. She was very flexible with when she could meet with us. She also got us a great deal on the house we sold.
Fillmore, IN Homeowner

I had some uncertainty about selling our home as we had had bad luck int he past. When we spoke to Tonya, she really alleviated all of my fears. She answered all of my questions thoroughly, genuinely and efficiently. Tonya then helped us sell our house (sold within 24 hours of listing!) and helped us buy a house that we love! She was with us every step of the way and she made sure that we felt comfortable throughout the process. I couldn’t have asked for a better agent and would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy, sell, or even just browse through the housing market.
Indianapolis, IN Homeowner

Successfully producing results in the area…

View this interactive sold map along with even more testimonials from clients in the Indianapolis area on our Zillow profile page.

How much is your home worth?

We’d be happy to provide you an estimate of the value of your home. Email us for details!

Real Estate Survival Guide: Buyer’s Checklist


Figure out how much house you can afford.

  • Calculate your monthly income and debt.
  • Check your credit report and FICO score.
  • Figure out your down payment.

Get pre-approved for a mortgage.

  • Choose a type of mortgage.
  • Speak to a mortgage lender.
  • Shop for the best interest rates and programs.

Determine what you want and need in a home.

  • Choose a location (downtown, urban, suburban, rural).
  • Choose a type (single family, townhouse, condo, loft).
  • Choose a price range.
  • Choose a size.
  • Choose an architectural style.

Research your target neighborhoods.

  • Call your real estate agent for details.

Searching for a home?

Click here to see our current listings and search all listings in the area.

Tonya McCarthy

Broker/ Realtor/Team Leader

Tonya McCarthy promotes integrity, energy, and determination in every detail of her real estate transaction. Tonya grew up in the Dallas, Texas area where she started her sales career in the banking industry. After moving on to work in a title and escrow business, she quickly realized her passion to help others find their dream homes.

In just 2 years, Tonya has established a successful career in real estate. Accomplishing no less than a five star rating from her clients, she has worked diligently in every aspect of the industry representing sellers and buyers in the residential market.

Tonya has an amazing family life as the mother of two wonderful boys, Drew and Collin, and the wife to a very supportive husband, Adam.

Tonya has established resources and partnerships in place to help her business run and operate successfully. She understands what it is like to stand in her client’s shoes. After relocating 2 times, Tonya has sensitivity towards her client’s journey.

If you are looking for personable service, honesty and drive, give Tonya a call today!

Partners and Resources for You

Home Warranty

America’s Preferred Home Warranty, Inc.
A home warranty can protect you in case of a major failure within your home; such as with kitchen appliances, plumbing, furnace, air conditioning, septic, roof, water heater, trash compactor, water well pump, attic and exhaust fans, electrical systems and more. Regular maintenance is essential for keeping a house functioning, but occasionally a malfunction can occur that requires repairs or replacement to restore the situation.